fivebass52 wrote:
but as far as your comment on the disadvantage... do they "really" need to be angled? If they were in the typical "straight" positions, how would that effect tone, if at all?
On the SG style I've put a Chines toaster style humbucker in the straight position underneath the mudbucker housing, It sounds okay, but if the pickup is positioned at an angle the sound will be a little bit more balanced from string to string.
I hated the mudbucker sound so when I replaced the innards with the toaster I could play around a bit with the pickup position. On this bass the difference between angled and straight was marginal, however the distance to bridge saddles is less extreme than on the 5 string basses.
When positioning the pickups straight it would kill the overall looks of the bass, done some CAD experiments with only the neck layout and the bridge for that. To me as a builder the looks is also an important factor!