Addison, you pretty much nailed it. I didn't see anything else that you described.
As y'all know I'm a big Wyn fanboi. It would really take an act of desperation for me to sell the one I have. I SO wanted to take one of those lefties home with me. However my accountant (sic. the wife
) talked me out of it as I have other gear priorities scheduled for this year. But I'll tell ya, it would have been the best "nice to have but not needed bass" in my collection! I am thankful that my accountant helps me rationalize my gear purchases. With her, it's about the priority and not the budget. Boy, did I marry the right girl!!! But I digress. Oh, one other thing about the lefty's. The one strung righty is pre sold, the one strung lefty is not, and may not be for sale. Randy continues to be lefty-friendly and since he builds 30 basses a year max and has an almost 3 year wait list, he's on the fence about selling it since he wants to have something to bring to shows for us lefty folk.
Question tho, did you try it through the Aggie or the Shuttle? IMHO Randy's basses sound their best through Shuttles or amps of similar ilk in active mode. In passive mode they do well through tube amps with sealed cabinets. Sounds altogether like a different animal. I wasn't in love with the tone thru the Aggie. And this years lefty's have some kind of Aggie preamp in them, whereas my does not.
Again Addison is spot on about that F Bass, I'd give it best of show for lefty's as well. F bass knows how to build lefty's that's for damn sure.
The Carvin was OK, typical Icon bass, nothing to write home about that hasn't been said before. However, they had a righty Vanquish fretless with their "Hard As My Granite Countertops" epoxy finish on the fretboard. I played it through their BX1600 amp and IIRC a 210 sitting on top of a 115 stack. Not sure what roundwound strings were on it. Took a while to dial in the mwah factor cause those strings were real zingy, but I was suitably impressed once I got it dialed in. It doesn't compare to an F bass or Zon fless of course, but for a $1400 bass it held it's own. And I liked the form factor of the body and neck a lot. They couldn't tell me what the string spacing was. It wasn't 19mm fo' sho' but it was damn close. I'm thinking it would get way closer to the Jaco tone with different strings and a nice chorus.
From what I could tell above the din in the booth the BX1600 is a good amp, I think it'll do well for Carvin.
As for the Fodera, I'll agree with most of what Addison wrote, but really, that bass did nothing for me at all. I didn't pay attention the saddle and nut details as mentioned. But I couldn't get those Fodera tones. I couldn't get much in the way of any tone through their headphone setup. Yes, the build quality was there as one would expect, but I tone tapped the bass back and top and neck with my ears pressed against the wood and all I can say is "meh". Didn't find the wood to be resonant, it felt kinda lifeless to me. Oh well, c'est la vie.
I avoided MusicMan like the plague, way too crowded and noisy by the time I got there.
Ric had a real nice 4003FG with an excellent neck profile compared to the one they had on display last year. Last year's model felt like a Louisville Slugger. This one was much more flatter, a lot more like their 70's profile which I like a lot. When I asked a rep, he told me "Well they're all unique you know, they all get their final shaping done by hand". This is the 1st time I've ever heard that one from a Ric employee, so I dunno, my BS meter kinda went up a bit when I heard that. Your opinions are welcome on this subject!
Sandberg - another tidbit about the relic'd Jazz bass. It has painted on black blocks. IIRC it retails for almost $2900. For that kinda $$$ you can do a lot better elsewhere. I didn't try the UMBO as there were a couple of slap-happy geeks dueling it out at the booth when I was there.
There is a new brand of bass amp called Trickfish. The preamp is designed by Mike Pope. The power module is identical to the power module used in the JBL PRX powered P.A. cabs. I know this as I talked for about an hour to the guy from Harman (JBL) who is one of the Trickfish team members. I spent more time talking about P.A. stuff (since my P.A. is a JBL PRX series) than the actual bass amp LOL. They have the typical cab line up: 1x15,1x12, 2x12, 2x10, 4x10. The 10's and 12's are NEO, The 15's are ceramic and the 1x15 weighs like 76 lbs. The cabs on the single 15's are about twice as deep as a Berg NV115. Imagine rotating an NV11 on it's side and that's pretty much what the front of their 1x15 cab looks like. It's front ported. The back, sides and bracing(!!!!) are multi-ply Baltic Birch which helps explains the weight factor as well. I have no doubt one of those 1x15's would get most of us through a typical bar gig.