danomite64 wrote:
Similar product? Seems to me Rod focuses on Precision-type basses, while Pete's more of a Jazz bass builder. If you think those are similar, I encourage you to check out the 400 'P vs J' threads on Talkbass........
Rod will be well able to speak for himself once he gets a chance to draw breath, but I think the point Andrew is making (and if it is then on that point I agree with him) is that Rod's approach is more focussed on getting the best from traditional materials, while Pete is more keen to explore the possibilities of newer materials and construction methods (carbon fibre isn't that new as a neck material btw - one of my former students turned up to a lesson with a Yamaha bass sporting a CF neck around 5 or 6 years ago; and the Bond guitar as used by Charlie Burchill of Simple Minds dates all the way back to the mid 80's) - perhaps we should say 'alternative technologies' rather than 'newer materials'.
Where they do cross over is in the production of instruments inspired by Fender originals, specifically the 'J' and 'P' designs. Also they are pitching their respective products at around the same price point, which will put them in the thoughts of the same buying sector.
Personally I'd love to see someone do a comparison of instruments from the two stables - not to say which might be better, but more to compare the results that the different design philosophies yield.